Tuesday, February 21, 2012

Final- Dickens Portrayal of the Real Hero

Victorian ideals glorified the wealthy, high social class. Oscar Wilde, in Portrait of Dorain Gray, introduced a good looking and wealthy young gentleman, the usual protagonist in works of the era only contrasted by weak willed and insignificant characters of lower social class (Wilde). One author stands out against the grain of the usual novels of the era-- Charles Dickens. Using characters from unsatisfying backgrounds, Dickens proves that your upbringing does not determine your future .
Charles Dickens was raised in a less than optimum house hold. He was not raised a privileged child and his parents had to work hard for the little that they had. When his father drove them into debt, he was forced to quit school at the age of twelve to start working in the factory. Dickens was so “ashamed of having been forced to leave school and do manual labor that he never told anyone in his own family about the incident” (Tobin 3). When his father’s debt was finally cleared and Dickens grew into his own manhood, he worked his way into his position of power in the world of journalism, eventually publishing novels piece by piece in the paper. His humble beginnings led him to see the corruption on societies views of lower class individuals, claiming that:

" [my] society wrongly valued economic transactions over natural human interactions, which resulted in a minous transference of commercial interests from the public sphere into the private" (Tobin 1).

Economic transitions becoming social meant that the lower class, who could not afford many economic transitions, became essentially closed off from the social world.
Dickens characters commonly follow the same life path he did. The archetypal Dickens character is a younger man who faces social challenges because of his social standings. In Great Expectations, for example Phillip ‘Pip’ Pirrip, an orphaned young man who lives with his borderline abusive sister and her blacksmith husband, raised in the swamps of England, lives in a low social class. He is looked down upon by not only his social superiors, but even his own family. At the same time, he looks down on them when he begins to see that “adopting an immoral and inhumane ideal of respectability”, eventually rejecting his only friend and practically his father, Joe (Tobin 5).
Death introduces us to Pips life when Magwitch, who remains unnamed at the time, and threatens his life as he stands over his parents grave. His helping Magwitch leads to his life as a Gentleman after “Pip comes to recognize Magwitch as a human being with emotions and the right  to be treated in a decent, humane manner” (Tobin 10). He saw that the man needed help, and aided by the threat of becoming his ‘whittles’, he saw that he needed to help this man. When he became a gentleman, he lost this sweet nature. This transition becomes simplified by  introducing to the ideas of the gentleman life by visiting Miss Havisham and Estella, the ‘femme fatale’ of the novel. Estella was a gorgeous young woman was trained to break men’s hearts, and she hardened Pip by proving to him “Take nothing on its looks; take everything on evidence. There's no better rule" (Great Expectations 29). Despite the downturns in his life, Pip managed a happy successful life, despite being raised by an abusive sister in a low class home, he managed to get the girl- granted after some heartbreak- and live successfully, proving that social class does not limit an individual. The individual limits their potential social class.
Tale of Two Cities, a earlier piece by Dickens set during the French Revolution, shows two different character types, Dickens archetypal and a Dickens version of the usual Victorian era characters. Sydney Carton, a usual Dickens character, appears only a lazy, alcoholic lawyer with no potential, even describing his own life as if it was a waste of time. Carton was supportive of the revolution despite his grim look on life claiming that “[He sees] the evil of this time and of the previous time of which this is the natural birth, gradually making expiation  for itself and wearing out" (Tale of Two Cities Chapter 3). When Sydney dies, he becomes a martyr for the cause of the revolution, redeeming his past as a lazy, depressing, drunkard.
Charles Darnay, another Tale of Two Cities character, comes  from a different social background than the usual Dickens character. Darnay was raised in the commonly portrayed Victorian lifestyle of elegance, but he denies the frivolous french aristocratic life style of his family, especially in a time of revolution. He chooses instead to reside in England to disassociate himself from his family and background. Despite the fact that Charles was raised in a higher class, he still had to overcome the views of his class. In this tumultuous revolution, the French aristocracy was looked down upon by the masses. With the exception of this, Charles was a rather flat character that follows the archetypal ‘hero’. He lacks a real, compelling conflict.
Great Expectations and Tale of Two Cities provide three examples of Dickens’s usual  characters. These men, all coming from unsatisfactory backgrounds, managed to create a successful lifestyle according to their own terms. Pip, who was raised an orphan and abused by his sister, built up a life where he had money and was appreciated by the people that surrounded him. Sydney Carlton, who never appreciated his own life, became a martyr for a great cause, giving him a reason for existence. Even Darnay, one of the flattest characters in the novel was able to escape the prejudice of his family’s social class.
The characters represented throughout Dickens extensive list of works, show that you can escape the bounds of your own social class. Victorian era individuals believed that money was power, and Dickens was one of the few author of the time that disproved this ideal. Authors like Oscar Wilde, of the same era, wrote of wealthy and sophisticated men, like the well mannered and good looking Dorian Gray, in Portrait of Dorian Gray (Wilde). Characters that played the lead in Dickens novel were used as stock background characters with no purpose because  “Individuals with disabilities...would strip the character's exceptional disability of its rhetorical power" (Marchbanks 1). Authors spun characters with disabilities into a spectacle, like a freak show in a circus (Marchbanks). Dickens proves that personality and drive determine a person success, not their social standing. Another one of Dickens’s characters, Smike, was shown that boundaries are made to be broken when “one considers the former evidence of Smike's faulty  memory in conjunction with his surprising ability to navigate London's winding streets, not only those walked multiple times with Nicholas, but those he has never traversed except in a state of panic" (Marchbanks 9), proving that even those who face serious mental incompetency can achieve a standard.
Dickens even attempted to stand up for the most unrepresented group throughout all of history-- women. Dickens portrayals of women, often seen as cold, have many feminist influences in his female characters. Estella, a cold hearted girl who was trained only to break men’s hearts, but she is also was a strong and confident young woman. He was said to often “[Cry] over lost women, repentant prostitutes, and dying impoverished girls--provided none of  these women were wives or political reformers--were causes Dickens loved to champion and did" (Schechner 7).
Dickens represented all of the underprivileged, proving that  boundaries do not truly exist. Dickens’s male and female characters showed the importance of character and perseverance over money and social class. Dickens proved to a large majority of people in his time that goals are attainable through characters in his novels like Great Expectations and Tale of Two Cities.










Works Cited
Dickens, Charles. Great Expectations. Amazon: Public Domain Publishers. 17 Mar. 2006
E-Book.
Dickens, Charles. Tale of Two Cities. Amazon: Public Domain Publishers. 1 Dec. 2010. E-Book.
Marchbanks, Paul. “From Caricature to Character: The Intellectually Disabled in Dickens
Novels”. Ebsco Host. 10 April 2006. Online Periodical.
Tobin, Mary Ann. “Critical Contents: From Sham to ‘Gentle Christian Man’ in Great Expectations”
24 Feb. 2010. Ebsco Host. Online Periodical.
Schechner, Peter. “Gender and Class in Dickens: Making Connections” Ebsco Host. 24 Feb.
2010. Online Periodical.
Wilde, Oscar. The Portrait of Dorian Grey. Amazon:Public Domain Publishers. 1 Oct. 1994.
E-Book

Thursday, February 16, 2012

Research Paper First Draft




Victorian ideals glorified the wealthy, high social class. Oscar Wilde, in Portrait of Dorain Gray, introduced a good looking and wealthy young gentleman, the usual protagonist in works of the era only to be contrasted by weak willed and insignificant characters of lower social class. One author stands out against the grain of the usual novels of the era- Charles Dickens. Using characters from unsatisfying backgrounds, Dickens proves that your upbringing does not determine your future .
Charles Dickens was raised in a less than optimum house hold. He was not raised a privileged child and his parents had to work hard for the little that they had. When his father drove them into debt, he was forced to quit school at the age of twelve to start working in the factory. Dickens was so “ashamed of having been forced to leave school and do manual labor that he never told anyone in his own family about the incident” (Tolbin 3). When his father’s debt was finally cleared and Dickens grew into his own manhood, he worked his way into his position of power in the world of journalism, eventually publishing novels piece by piece in the paper. His humble beginnings led him to see the corruption on the societal views of lower class individuals, claiming that:
" [my] society wrongly valued economic transactions over natural human interactions, which resulted in a minous transference of commercial interests from the public sphere into the private" (Tobin 1).

Economic transitions becoming social meant that the lower class, who could not afford many economic transitions, became essentially closed off from the social world.
Dickens characters commonly follow the same life path he did. The archetypal Dickens character is a younger man who faces social challenges because of his social standings. In Great Expectations, for example Phillip ‘Pip’ Pirrip is an orphaned young man who lives with his borderline abusive sister and her blacksmith husband. Pip being raised in the swamps of England by his sister and a laborer lives in a low social class. He is looked down upon by not only his social superiors, but even his own family. At the same time, he looks down on them when he begins to see that “adopting an immoral and inhumane ideal of respectability”, eventually rejecting his only friend and practically his father, Joe (Tolbin 5).
Death introduces us to Pips life when Magwitch, who remains unnamed at the time, and threatens his life as he stands over his parents grave. His helping Magwitch leads to his life as a Gentleman, he saw that “Pip comes to recognize Magwitch as a human being with emotions and the right  to be treated in a decent, humane manner” (Tolbin 10). He saw that the man needed help, and aided by the threat of being eaten, he saw that he needed to help this man. When he became a gentleman, he lost this sweet nature. This transition is simplified by being introduced to the ideas of the gentleman life by visiting Miss Havisham and Estella, the ‘femme fatale’ of the novel. Estella was a gorgeous young woman was trained to be a heart breaker, and she hardened Pip by proving to him “Take nothing on its looks; take everything on evidence. There's no better rule" (Dickens 29). Despite the downturns in his life, Pip managed a happy successful life, despite being raised by an abusive sister in a low class home, he managed to get the girl- granted after some heartbreak- and live successfully, proving that social class does not limit an individual. The individual limits their potential social class.
Tale of Two Cities, a earlier piece by Dickens set during the French Revolution, shows two different character types, Dickens archetypal and a Dickens version of the usual Victorian era characters. Sydney Carton, a usual Dickens character, appears to be a lazy, alcoholic lawyer with no potential, even describing his own life as if it were a waste of time. Carton was supportive of the revolution despite his grim look on life claim “[He sees] the evil of this time and of the previous time of which this is the natural birth, gradually making expiation  for itself and wearing out" (Dickens Chapter 3). When Sydney dies, he becomes a martyr for the cause of the revolution, redeeming his past as a lazy, depressing, drunkard.
Charles Darnay, another Tale of Two Cities character, comes  from a different social background than the usual Dickens Character. Darnay was raised in the commonly portrayed Victorian lifestyle of elegance, but he denies the frivolous french aristocratic life style of his family, especially in a time of revolution. He chooses instead to reside in England to disassociate himself from his family and background. Despite the fact that Charles was raised in a higher class, he still had to overcome the views of his class. In this tumultuous revolution, the French aristocracy was looked down upon by the masses. With the exception of this, Charles was a rather flat character that follows the archetypal ‘hero’, he lacks a real, compelling conflict.
Great Expectations and Tale of Two Cities provide three examples of Dickens’s usual  characters. These men, all coming from unsatisfactory backgrounds, managed to create a successful lifestyle according to their own terms. Pip, who was raised an orphan and abused by his sister, built up a life where he had money and was appreciated by the people that surrounded him. Sydney Carlton, who never appreciated his own life, became a martyr for a great cause, giving him a reason for existence. Even Darnay, one of the flattest characters in the novel was able to escape the prejudice of his family’s social class.
The characters represented throughout Dickens extensive list of works, show that you can escape the bounds of your own social class. Victorian era individuals believed that money was power, and Dickens was one of the few author of the time that disproved this ideal. Authors like Oscar Wilde, of the same era, wrote of wealthy and sophisticated men. Character that played the lead in Dickens novel were used as stock background characters with no purpose because  “Individuals with disabilities...would strip the character's exceptional disability of its rhetorical power" (Marchbanks 1). Authors spun characters with disabilities into a spectacle, like a freak show in a circus (Marchbanks). Dickens proves that personality and drive determine a person success, not their social standing. Another one of Dickens’s characters, Smike, was shown that boundaries are made to be broken when “one considers the former evidence of Smike's faulty  memory in conjunction with his surprising ability to navigate London's winding streets, not only those walked multiple times with Nicholas, but those he has never traversed except in a state of panic" (Marchbanks 9), proving that even those who face serious mental incompetency can achieve a standard.
Dickens even attempted to stand up for the most unrepresented group throughout all of history-- women. While Dickens portrayal of women is often seen as cold, Dickens has many feminist influences in his female characters. Estella is a cold hearted girl who was trained only to break men’s hearts, but she is also was a strong and confident young woman. He was said to often “Crying over lost women, repentant prostitutes, and dying impoverished girls--provided none of  these women were wives or political reformers--were causes Dickens loved to champion and did" (Schechner 7). He represented all of the underprivileged proving that there truly are no boundaries.  

Monday, February 6, 2012

Research Essay Outline

Thesis Statement:
Dickens use of underprivileged characters, in opposition to similar character is other stories for the same era, brought otherwise juvenile characters to the forefront and make achieving your goals seem attainable.


Body Paragraph 1:
-Dickens 'typical' character. (A socially inept or disabled you man who grows into a socially acceptable lifestyle)
- Parallel to Dickens personal life 
                     i)1)"Charles Dickens believed that his society wrongly valued economic transactions over natural
                          human interactions, which resulted in a minous transference of commercial interests from the 
                           public sphere into the private" (Tobin 1). 


                       2)"Dickens himself was conflicted about his right to respectability, and many of his characters
                           suffer the strain of not knowing where or how they flt in. Dickens's father, John,was perpetually
                           in debt, which led to Dickens's brief employment in Warren's Blacking Factory at the age of 
                           twelve. Dickens was so ashamed of having been forced to leave school and do manual labor
                           that he never told anyone in his own family about the incident. After his father's debts were
                           cleared and Dickens grew to manhood, he worked his way up the social ladder, initially
                           applying his skills as a shorthand writer at the various courts of law in London and as a 
                           journalist" (Tolbin 3). 
-How Dickens's personal life influenced his characters.

Body Paragraph 2:
-Introduction to Pip:
            i) Orphaned, apprentice to Joe the Blacksmith
           ii) Becomes friendly with gentlemen and women
          iii) becomes a gentleman through his helping others.
                        3) "Pip's transferring onto Joe his own feelings of inferiority as well as his desires to eradicate 
                              their outward appearances signal the young man's first step toward adopting an immoral and
                              inhumane ideal of respectability" (Tobin 5). 

                        4)"Over time, Pip comes to recognize Magwitch as a human being with emotions and the right 
                             to be treated in a decent, humane manner. However, Pip does not completely transfer the
                             compassion he learned during his own sickness from Joe to Magwitch until the convict is
                            once again arrested, that is, at the point of no return" (Tolbin 10)
-How Pip achieved his Gentleman status. 
            i)Though helping others who were not of the same social stability as he was. (Magwitch)
                         5) "Take nothing on its looks; take everything on evidence. There's no better rule" (Dickens 29).

-
The male characters of Tale of Two cities:
Body Paragraph 3:
                   i) Charles Darnay
                           -Unusual Dickens Character. Is born into power, but shuns their ideal to live his own life
                           -Shows that success is in the eye of the beholder.
                  ii) Sydney Carton
                           - Typical Dickens character redeemed from his alcoholism.
                           6) "I see a beautiful city and a brilliant people rising from this abyss, and, in their struggles to
                               be truly free, in their triumphs and defeats, through long years to come, I see the evil of this 
                               time and of the previous time of which this is the natural birth, gradually making expiation
                               for itself and wearing out." (Dickens Chapter 3).

Body Paragraph 4:
-Compare Characters:
                  i) Pip VS Charles
                         - Both reach their eventual success and reject what would have been considered their success 
                          based on their birth rights
                 ii) Pip VS Sydney
                         - Both redeem themselves from a low point, either being in debt or alcoholism.
                iii) Sydney VS Charles
                         -Both reach their own definitions of spiritual success rather than success socially or with 
                          money.
Body Paragraph 5:
-Why does the archetype of Dickens characters matter?
                ~It shows a contrast to other stories of the same time that focused strictly on men of a high social
                  class and the dickens type of character is more of a joke character.
                       7)"The physically disabled character's very distinctiveness can lead, not only to isolation from 
                           those other fictional persons who react with distancing pity or disgust, but to a kind of
                           representational disconnect from those real-world individuals with disabilities whose numbers-
                           recognized within the boundary of the novel or short story-would strip the character's 
                           exceptional disability of its rhetorical power" (Marchbanks 1).
-Personality is more important than the characters social standing 
                      8) "Dickens appears unable, or unwilling, to present a coherent portrait of Smike's mental 
                           faculties. Here, the narrator prevents unequivocal praise of Smike's heroic intentions by mixing
                           proof of his valor with doubt about whether the boy's scattered "thoughts" are even worth the
                           name. Other inconsistencies emerge if one considers the former evidence of Smike's faulty 
                           memory in conjunction with his surprising ability to navigate London's winding streets, not only
                           those walked multiple times with Nicholas, but those he has never traversed except in a state
                           of panic" (Marchbanks 9)
                       9) Victorian authors spun disability into a spectacle, like a freak show in a circus, but Dickens
                           used the disabilities of the characters as a conflict that tried to hold them back, that they had 
                           to either over come, or grow to accept. (Marchbanks) Paraphrase 
-Contrast with Oscar Wilde's Dorian Gray, a man of wealth and looks and a high social standing.
Body Paragraph 6:
-What does Dickens Characters show people of the era?
                 ~During the time, most people were in the place of Dickens characters. It gave hope for those who
                    weren't of the highest social stand, like Dickens as a child, the hope to be able to achieve more 
                    than what their parents or guardians were able to achieve.
                ~Dickens cared for the average citizen, including the women:
                     10)"Crying over lost women, repentant prostitutes, and dying impoverished girls--provided none of 
                           these women were wives or political reformers--were causes Dickens loved to champion and
                           did" (Schechner 7). 


Thursday, January 26, 2012

Proposal

Research Proposal: Charles Dickens's Great Expectations and Tale of Two Cities


Proposed Thesis Statement:
Dickens use of underprivileged characters, in opposition to similar character is other stories for the same era, brought otherwise juvenile characters to the forefront and make achieving your goals seem attainable.

Claims:
-With the exception of Dickens, most authors of the era made the low class and socially and or physically challenged people jester characters, that were there for pity, or as a break in the dramatic dialogue. Dickens instead chose to make them- and their eventual success- the main focus of the story.
-Most of the underprivileged characters in Dickens novels are questioned and made to believe that they can not achieve their goals; They eventually do achieve them. Dickens novels are the archetype of an under-dog story.
-Dickens parallels the challenges he faced in his own life, going from an under privileged boy, to a successful man.
-Wealth does not determine ones worth.

Documents Used:
-Great Expectations by Charles Dickens (re-read novel)
-Tale of Two Cities by Charles Dickens (new novel from the same author)
-'Gender and Class in Dickens: Making Connections' (Literary Critique)
-'Critical Contents: from Sham to 'Good Christian Man' in Great Expectations' (Literary Critique)
-'From Caricature to Character: The Intellectually Disabled in Dickens Novels (Part One)' (Literary Critique)

Characters to be Analyzed: (To be edited depending on running length)
-Phillip 'Pip' Pirrip - Great Expectations protagonist
                > Pip is an Orphan raised by his sister who, despite his low class beginnings, becomes a
                    Gentleman.

-Abel Magwitch - Great Expectations character
                 >An escaped convict. After Pip brings him 'wittles and a file' he feels he must repay him. After
                     his second escape, he goes to America and becomes successful and eventually funds Pips life
                     as a Gentleman

- Herbert Pocket - Great Expectations character
                 > Pip's best friend when he moves to London to become a Gentleman. They meet during a fight
                      in Miss Havisham's garden

-Charles Darnay - Tale of Two Cities protagonist
                  > Special exception as his is actually part of the aristocracy, but chooses to live against his birth.

-Sydney Carton - Tale of Two Cities character
                  > Arguably more of an architypical Dickens protagonist, Sydney is an alcoholic attorney who
                       eventually redeems himself.

- Doctor Manette- Tale of Two Cities character
                   > The Father of Lucie and a Doctor who is imprisoned and distracts himself by making shoes.  
                       He eventually proves himself a worthy and loving man who would do anything for his
                       daughter
 
- Monsieur Defarge- Tale of Two Cities character
                    > A French Revolutionist and wine shoppe owner, Monsieur Defarge is a strong leader and is
                       willing to make a change at any cost, but shows kindness unlike his wife Madame Defarge.